// MOTIONS PLATFORM — Master Data Layer // Exposed as window.MOTIONS_DATA — firm-wide motion-practice intelligence const MOTIONS_DATA = { kpis: { activeMotions: 42, drafting: 8, partnerReview: 6, filed: 14, underSubmission: 9, grantedYtd: 64, grantedInPartYtd: 18, deniedYtd: 22, avgWinRate: 71.4, // (granted + 0.5 * partial) / decided — YTD dueThisWeek: 7, dueNext30: 21, oralArgsNext14: 5, briefBankEntries: 184, templatesActive: 32, avgCiteCount: 34, // per motion avgPageCount: 24, rulingsReceivedYtd: 104, avgDaysToRuling: 38, attorneysInvolved: 18, totalCitations: 1_428, // tracked across active motions }, // ── MOTIONS — all active (42 shown; representative 24) ── motions: [ { id: 'M-9042', type: 'Motion for Summary Judgment', captionShort: 'Redstone MSJ Opposition', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', matterId: 'M-2024-0312', court: 'Del. Ch.', judge: 'V.C. Laster', filedDate: '2026-04-10', hearingDate: '2026-05-28', status: 'Fully Briefed', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 48, cites: 56, wordsTarget: 14000, wordsCurrent: 13840, pct: 98.9, opposing: 'Harrison Defense Group', kind: 'Opposition', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 68%' }, { id: 'M-9041', type: 'Motion to Compel Brady', captionShort: 'Harrell Compel Brady', matter: 'United States v. Harrell', matterId: 'M-2025-0384', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Hellerstein', filedDate: '2026-02-24', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Under Submission', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 18, cites: 22, wordsTarget: 5000, wordsCurrent: 5000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA S. Chen', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part — 62%' }, { id: 'M-9040', type: 'Motion to Dismiss', captionShort: 'Venkataraman MTD (HHS-OIG Estoppel)', matter: 'United States v. Venkataraman', matterId: 'M-2025-0218', court: 'E.D. Pa.', judge: 'Pappert', filedDate: '2026-02-18', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Awaiting Argument', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 38, cites: 44, wordsTarget: 11000, wordsCurrent: 10840, pct: 98.5, opposing: 'AUSA M. Reyes', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part — 48%' }, { id: 'M-9039', type: 'Franks Hearing Motion', captionShort: 'Miller Franks', matter: 'United States v. Miller', matterId: 'M-2025-0302', court: 'E.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Matsumoto', filedDate: '2026-02-20', hearingDate: '2026-05-08', status: 'Granted', author: 'J. Park', pages: 22, cites: 31, wordsTarget: 6000, wordsCurrent: 6000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA R. Harding', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted ok' }, { id: 'M-9038', type: 'Motion to Suppress (4th Amend.)', captionShort: 'Miller Suppress', matter: 'United States v. Miller', matterId: 'M-2025-0302', court: 'E.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Matsumoto', filedDate: '2026-02-20', hearingDate: '2026-04-30', status: 'Awaiting Argument', author: 'J. Park', pages: 26, cites: 28, wordsTarget: 7000, wordsCurrent: 7000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA R. Harding', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 70% (contingent on Franks)' }, { id: 'M-9037', type: 'Motion in Limine — Exclude Patient Testimony', captionShort: 'Venkat MIL Patient Narrative', matter: 'United States v. Venkataraman', matterId: 'M-2025-0218', court: 'E.D. Pa.', judge: 'Pappert', filedDate: '2026-03-28', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Filed', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 14, cites: 18, wordsTarget: 4000, wordsCurrent: 4000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA M. Reyes', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part — 55%' }, { id: 'M-9036', type: 'Motion for New Trial — Rule 33', captionShort: 'Barnwell New Trial (Brady)', matter: 'United States v. Barnwell', matterId: 'M-2025-0721', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Engelmayer', filedDate: '2026-03-30', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Awaiting Argument', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 32, cites: 38, wordsTarget: 8000, wordsCurrent: 8000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA T. Park', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Denied — 72% (long shot)' }, { id: 'M-9035', type: 'Daubert Motion', captionShort: 'Okonkwo Exclude Gov\'t Expert', matter: 'United States v. Okonkwo', matterId: 'M-2024-0139', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Caproni', filedDate: '2026-03-18', hearingDate: '2026-04-22', status: 'Granted in Part', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 24, cites: 32, wordsTarget: 7000, wordsCurrent: 7000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA D. Lee', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part ok' }, { id: 'M-9034', type: 'Motion in Limine — 404(b)', captionShort: 'Okonkwo 404(b)', matter: 'United States v. Okonkwo', matterId: 'M-2024-0139', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Caproni', filedDate: '2026-03-20', hearingDate: '2026-04-22', status: 'Granted in Part', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 18, cites: 22, wordsTarget: 5000, wordsCurrent: 5000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA D. Lee', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part ok' }, { id: 'M-9033', type: 'Motion for Class Certification', captionShort: 'Greenfield Class Cert', matter: 'Greenfield Environmental', matterId: 'M-2024-0215', court: 'N.D. Cal.', judge: 'Gonzalez Rogers', filedDate: '2026-04-02', hearingDate: '2026-06-12', status: 'Opposition Pending', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 62, cites: 84, wordsTarget: 18000, wordsCurrent: 17840, pct: 99.1, opposing: 'Greenfield Legal', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 58%' }, { id: 'M-9032', type: 'Motion to Quash Subpoena', captionShort: 'Ó Briain Grand Jury Quash', matter: 'United States v. Ó Briain', matterId: 'M-2026-0018', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Liman', filedDate: '2026-03-10', hearingDate: '2026-03-25', status: 'Denied', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 14, cites: 16, wordsTarget: 4000, wordsCurrent: 4000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA J. Kang', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Denied ok' }, { id: 'M-9031', type: 'Sentencing Memorandum — § 3553(a)', captionShort: 'Whitman Sentencing Memo', matter: 'United States v. Whitman', matterId: 'M-2025-0134', court: 'D.D.C.', judge: 'Moss', filedDate: '2026-04-15', hearingDate: '2026-05-22', status: 'Filed', author: 'R. Vasquez', pages: 28, cites: 21, wordsTarget: 8000, wordsCurrent: 8000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA B. Osei', kind: 'Memorandum', expectedOutcome: 'Variance 8-12 mo — 65%' }, { id: 'M-9030', type: 'Sentencing Memorandum', captionShort: 'Barnwell Sentencing Memo', matter: 'United States v. Barnwell', matterId: 'M-2025-0721', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Engelmayer', filedDate: null, hearingDate: '2026-06-04', status: 'Drafting', author: 'L. Torres', pages: null, cites: 14, wordsTarget: 10000, wordsCurrent: 6400, pct: 64.0, opposing: 'AUSA T. Park', kind: 'Memorandum', expectedOutcome: '72-mo variance — 60%' }, { id: 'M-9029', type: 'Motion to Sever', captionShort: 'Harrell Sever Count 4', matter: 'United States v. Harrell', matterId: 'M-2025-0384', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', judge: 'Hellerstein', filedDate: '2026-03-14', hearingDate: '2026-04-14', status: 'Denied', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 16, cites: 19, wordsTarget: 4500, wordsCurrent: 4500, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA S. Chen', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Denied ok' }, { id: 'M-9028', type: 'Motion for Bail Review', captionShort: 'Chen § 3145(b)', matter: 'United States v. Chen', matterId: 'M-2026-0042', court: 'D.D.C.', judge: 'Bates', filedDate: '2026-03-04', hearingDate: '2026-03-18', status: 'Denied', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 22, cites: 24, wordsTarget: 6000, wordsCurrent: 6000, pct: 100, opposing: 'AUSA F. Diaz', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Denied ok — appeal filed' }, { id: 'M-9027', type: 'Appellate Brief — Detention', captionShort: 'Chen D.C. Cir. Brief', matter: 'United States v. Chen', matterId: 'M-2026-0042', court: 'D.C. Cir.', judge: '3-judge panel', filedDate: '2026-04-04', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Awaiting Argument', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 48, cites: 52, wordsTarget: 14000, wordsCurrent: 14000, pct: 100, opposing: 'Appellate Section — DOJ', kind: 'Brief', expectedOutcome: 'Reversal — 52%' }, { id: 'M-9026', type: 'Motion to Compel', captionShort: 'Redstone Board Minutes', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', matterId: 'M-2024-0312', court: 'Del. Ch.', judge: 'V.C. Laster', filedDate: '2026-04-04', hearingDate: '2026-04-28', status: 'Under Submission', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 18, cites: 24, wordsTarget: 5000, wordsCurrent: 5000, pct: 100, opposing: 'Harrison Defense Group', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part — 64%' }, { id: 'M-9025', type: 'Motion for Sanctions — Rule 37(e)', captionShort: 'Redstone Osei Spoliation', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', matterId: 'M-2024-0312', court: 'Del. Ch.', judge: 'V.C. Laster', filedDate: '2026-04-02', hearingDate: '2026-05-05', status: 'Opposition Pending', author: 'L. Torres', pages: 38, cites: 42, wordsTarget: 11000, wordsCurrent: 11000, pct: 100, opposing: 'Harrison Defense Group', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Adverse inference — 58%' }, { id: 'M-9024', type: 'Motion to Dismiss', captionShort: 'Pacific Shipping MTD', matter: 'Pacific Shipping Antitrust', matterId: 'M-2024-0456', court: '9th Cir.', judge: 'Gonzalez Rogers', filedDate: null, hearingDate: '2026-05-22', status: 'Drafting', author: 'S. Chen', pages: null, cites: 38, wordsTarget: 15000, wordsCurrent: 9800, pct: 65.3, opposing: 'Defense Consortium', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Denied — 60%' }, { id: 'M-9023', type: 'Class Certification Reply', captionShort: 'Pacific Shipping Reply', matter: 'Pacific Shipping Antitrust', matterId: 'M-2024-0456', court: '9th Cir.', judge: 'Gonzalez Rogers', filedDate: null, hearingDate: '2026-06-02', status: 'Drafting', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: null, cites: 31, wordsTarget: 10000, wordsCurrent: 6200, pct: 62.0, opposing: 'Defense Consortium', kind: 'Reply', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 58%' }, { id: 'M-9022', type: 'Markman Claim Construction Brief', captionShort: 'Blackwell Markman', matter: 'Blackwell IP', matterId: 'M-2024-0611', court: 'D. Del.', judge: 'Williams', filedDate: '2026-04-15', hearingDate: '2026-06-03', status: 'Opposition Pending', author: 'A. Petrov', pages: 42, cites: 48, wordsTarget: 12000, wordsCurrent: 11800, pct: 98.3, opposing: 'Verge IP Counsel', kind: 'Brief', expectedOutcome: 'Pro-patentee — 55%' }, { id: 'M-9021', type: 'Daubert Motion', captionShort: 'Redstone Daubert (Harlan)', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', matterId: 'M-2024-0312', court: 'Del. Ch.', judge: 'V.C. Laster', filedDate: null, hearingDate: '2026-05-14', status: 'Partner Review', author: 'L. Torres', pages: null, cites: 22, wordsTarget: 4500, wordsCurrent: 4100, pct: 91.1, opposing: 'Harrison Defense Group', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted in part — 68%' }, { id: 'M-9020', type: 'Motion in Limine — Matter Expert', captionShort: 'Redstone MIL Harlan Scope', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', matterId: 'M-2024-0312', court: 'Del. Ch.', judge: 'V.C. Laster', filedDate: null, hearingDate: '2026-05-20', status: 'Drafting', author: 'L. Torres', pages: null, cites: 8, wordsTarget: 3500, wordsCurrent: 2100, pct: 60.0, opposing: 'Harrison Defense Group', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 60%' }, { id: 'M-9019', type: 'Motion for Protective Order', captionShort: 'Sterling DOJ Protective', matter: 'Sterling Pharma FCPA', matterId: 'M-2024-0701', court: 'D.D.C.', judge: 'Bates', filedDate: '2026-04-14', hearingDate: '2026-05-01', status: 'Opposition Pending', author: 'M. Kirkland', pages: 16, cites: 18, wordsTarget: 4500, wordsCurrent: 4500, pct: 100, opposing: 'DOJ FCPA Unit', kind: 'Motion', expectedOutcome: 'Granted — 72%' }, ], // ── DRAFTING WORKSPACES (active drafts with sections) ── drafts: [ { motionId: 'M-9030', caption: 'Sentencing Memorandum — Barnwell', author: 'L. Torres', lastEdit: '2h ago', sections: [ { id: 'S1', title: 'Introduction', words: 420, target: 500, status: 'complete', cites: 1 }, { id: 'S2', title: 'Procedural History', words: 680, target: 700, status: 'complete', cites: 2 }, { id: 'S3', title: 'Personal Characteristics (§ 3553(a)(1))',words: 1820, target: 2000, status: 'drafting', cites: 4 }, { id: 'S4', title: 'Nature & Circumstances of Offense', words: 1240, target: 1500, status: 'drafting', cites: 3 }, { id: 'S5', title: 'Collateral Consequences', words: 1100, target: 1200, status: 'complete', cites: 5 }, { id: 'S6', title: 'Variance Arguments', words: 1140, target: 3000, status: 'outlined', cites: 8 }, { id: 'S7', title: 'Conclusion', words: 0, target: 600, status: 'not-started', cites: 0 }, ], }, { motionId: 'M-9024', caption: 'Motion to Dismiss — Pacific Shipping', author: 'S. Chen', lastEdit: '4h ago', sections: [ { id: 'S1', title: 'Introduction', words: 680, target: 700, status: 'complete', cites: 2 }, { id: 'S2', title: 'Statement of Facts', words: 2840, target: 3000, status: 'complete', cites: 12 }, { id: 'S3', title: 'Argument I — Lack of Antitrust Injury',words: 2840, target: 4000, status: 'drafting', cites: 14 }, { id: 'S4', title: 'Argument II — Failure to State a Claim',words: 2100, target: 3500, status: 'drafting', cites: 8 }, { id: 'S5', title: 'Argument III — Statute of Limitations',words: 1340, target: 2500, status: 'drafting', cites: 6 }, { id: 'S6', title: 'Conclusion', words: 0, target: 500, status: 'not-started', cites: 0 }, ], }, { motionId: 'M-9023', caption: 'Class Certification Reply — Pacific Shipping', author: 'M. Kirkland', lastEdit: '6h ago', sections: [ { id: 'S1', title: 'Introduction', words: 480, target: 500, status: 'complete', cites: 1 }, { id: 'S2', title: 'Predominance', words: 2400, target: 3500, status: 'drafting', cites: 14 }, { id: 'S3', title: 'Damages Methodology', words: 1800, target: 2400, status: 'drafting', cites: 9 }, { id: 'S4', title: 'Typicality & Adequacy', words: 1200, target: 1500, status: 'drafting', cites: 4 }, { id: 'S5', title: 'Rebuttal to Opposition', words: 0, target: 1500, status: 'not-started', cites: 0 }, { id: 'S6', title: 'Conclusion', words: 320, target: 600, status: 'outlined', cites: 2 }, ], }, { motionId: 'M-9021', caption: 'Daubert Motion — Dr. Harlan', author: 'L. Torres', lastEdit: '1d ago', sections: [ { id: 'S1', title: 'Introduction', words: 420, target: 400, status: 'complete', cites: 1 }, { id: 'S2', title: 'Rule 702 Standard', words: 860, target: 900, status: 'complete', cites: 5 }, { id: 'S3', title: 'Dr. Harlan\'s Methodology Unreliable',words: 1680,target: 1800, status: 'complete', cites: 8 }, { id: 'S4', title: 'Market-Multiples Approach Not Peer-Reviewed', words: 940, target: 1000, status: 'complete', cites: 4 }, { id: 'S5', title: 'Remedy — Partial Exclusion', words: 200, target: 400, status: 'drafting', cites: 4 }, ], }, ], // ── BRIEF BANK ── (prior-winning briefs + snippets, organized by motion type / issue) briefBank: [ { id: 'BB-001', title: 'MSJ Opposition — Delaware BJR Framework', type: 'MSJ Opposition', matterOrigin: 'Redstone v. Meridian', winRate: '12 of 14 prior uses', pages: 48, cites: 56, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Corporate — BJR', lastUpdated: '2026-04-10', tags: ['BJR','MFW','fiduciary','Delaware'] }, { id: 'BB-002', title: 'Daubert — Economic Damages Methodology Challenge', type: 'Daubert', matterOrigin: 'Various', winRate: '18 of 22 prior uses', pages: 24, cites: 32, author: 'Litigation Group', category: 'Expert — Damages', lastUpdated: '2026-03-22', tags: ['Daubert','702','damages','regression'] }, { id: 'BB-003', title: 'Motion to Compel — Brady Materiality (Kyles)', type: 'Compel', matterOrigin: 'Multiple criminal', winRate: '14 of 18 prior uses', pages: 18, cites: 22, author: 'Criminal Defense', category: 'Criminal — Discovery', lastUpdated: '2026-02-24', tags: ['Brady','Kyles','Giglio','302s'] }, { id: 'BB-004', title: 'Motion in Limine — Patient Narrative (Rule 403)', type: 'MIL', matterOrigin: 'Healthcare Fraud matters', winRate: '8 of 10 prior uses', pages: 14, cites: 18, author: 'L. Torres', category: 'Criminal — Evidence', lastUpdated: '2026-03-28', tags: ['FRE 403','prejudice','patients'] }, { id: 'BB-005', title: 'Class Certification — Predominance (Comcast)', type: 'Class Cert', matterOrigin: 'Antitrust matters', winRate: '6 of 8 prior uses', pages: 42, cites: 58, author: 'S. Chen', category: 'Antitrust — Class', lastUpdated: '2026-04-02', tags: ['Comcast','Wal-Mart','predominance','Amex'] }, { id: 'BB-006', title: 'Franks Hearing — Officer Affiant Misstatement', type: 'Franks', matterOrigin: 'Criminal — Narcotics', winRate: '5 of 6 prior uses', pages: 22, cites: 31, author: 'J. Park', category: 'Criminal — 4th Amend.', lastUpdated: '2026-02-20', tags: ['Franks','affidavit','CI','probable cause'] }, { id: 'BB-007', title: 'Sanctions — Rule 37(e) Adverse Inference', type: 'Sanctions', matterOrigin: 'Redstone + Greenfield', winRate: '10 of 14 prior uses', pages: 38, cites: 42, author: 'L. Torres', category: 'Discovery — Spoliation', lastUpdated: '2026-04-02', tags: ['Rule 37(e)','spoliation','ESI','adverse inference'] }, { id: 'BB-008', title: 'Bail Pending Trial — § 3142 Flight Risk', type: 'Bail', matterOrigin: 'Criminal — Cross-border', winRate: '7 of 12 prior uses', pages: 22, cites: 24, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Criminal — Bail', lastUpdated: '2026-03-04', tags: ['§ 3142','flight risk','PRC','Kastigar'] }, { id: 'BB-009', title: '§ 3553(a) Variance — Acceptance + Cooperation', type: 'Sentencing', matterOrigin: 'Multiple criminal', winRate: '22 of 28 prior uses', pages: 28, cites: 21, author: 'Criminal Defense', category: 'Criminal — Sentencing', lastUpdated: '2026-04-15', tags: ['§ 3553(a)','variance','acceptance','cooperation'] }, { id: 'BB-010', title: 'Markman — §112(f) Means-Plus-Function', type: 'Markman', matterOrigin: 'Blackwell IP', winRate: '9 of 11 prior uses', pages: 42, cites: 48, author: 'A. Petrov', category: 'Patent — Claim Construction', lastUpdated: '2026-04-15', tags: ['Williamson','§ 112(f)','means-plus-function'] }, { id: 'BB-011', title: 'Motion to Dismiss — Securities PSLRA Scienter', type: 'MTD', matterOrigin: 'Securities — 10b-5', winRate: '6 of 10 prior uses', pages: 32, cites: 41, author: 'L. Torres', category: 'Securities — MTD', lastUpdated: '2026-03-20', tags: ['PSLRA','Tellabs','scienter','Iqbal'] }, { id: 'BB-012', title: 'Class Cert Reply — Amex Two-Sided Market', type: 'Class Cert Reply', matterOrigin: 'Pacific Shipping', winRate: '4 of 6 prior uses', pages: 32, cites: 28, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Antitrust — Class', lastUpdated: '2026-04-19', tags: ['Amex','two-sided','Sherman §1'] }, { id: 'BB-013', title: 'Motion to Quash — Grand Jury Subpoena Privilege', type: 'Quash', matterOrigin: 'Criminal — Investigation', winRate: '3 of 8 prior uses', pages: 14, cites: 16, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Criminal — Privilege', lastUpdated: '2026-03-10', tags: ['grand jury','attorney-client','privilege'] }, { id: 'BB-014', title: 'Protective Order — Confidential Investigation', type: 'Protective Order', matterOrigin: 'Sterling FCPA', winRate: '8 of 9 prior uses', pages: 16, cites: 18, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Criminal — Discovery', lastUpdated: '2026-04-14', tags: ['protective order','FCPA','DOJ'] }, { id: 'BB-015', title: 'Appellate Brief — Detention Appeal (§ 3145)', type: 'Appellate', matterOrigin: 'Criminal — Cross-border', winRate: '2 of 4 prior uses', pages: 48, cites: 52, author: 'M. Kirkland', category: 'Criminal — Appeal', lastUpdated: '2026-04-04', tags: ['D.C. Cir.','detention','§ 3145'] }, { id: 'BB-016', title: 'Motion for New Trial — Rule 33 Brady Post-Verdict', type: 'New Trial', matterOrigin: 'Barnwell', winRate: '1 of 3 prior uses', pages: 32, cites: 38, author: 'L. Torres', category: 'Criminal — Post-Trial', lastUpdated: '2026-03-30', tags: ['Rule 33','Brady','Wearry'] }, ], // ── CITATIONS (aggregate view — 80+ tracked; subset shown) ── citations: [ { id: 'C-001', short: 'MFW v. Kahn', cite: '88 A.3d 635 (Del. 2014)', motionIds: ['M-9042'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 8, firmUsage: 42, lastVerified: '2026-04-18' }, { id: 'C-002', short: 'Aronson v. Lewis', cite: '473 A.2d 805 (Del. 1984)', motionIds: ['M-9042'], treatment: 'caution', usesInMotion: 4, firmUsage: 38, lastVerified: '2026-04-17', flagNote: 'Partially abrogated by Zuckerberg (Del. 2021)' }, { id: 'C-003', short: 'Revlon', cite: '506 A.2d 173 (Del. 1986)', motionIds: ['M-9042'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 3, firmUsage: 34, lastVerified: '2026-04-15' }, { id: 'C-004', short: 'Unocal', cite: '493 A.2d 946 (Del. 1985)', motionIds: ['M-9042'], treatment: 'caution', usesInMotion: 2, firmUsage: 22, lastVerified: '2026-04-10' }, { id: 'C-005', short: 'Kyles v. Whitley', cite: '514 U.S. 419 (1995)', motionIds: ['M-9041'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 6, firmUsage: 48, lastVerified: '2026-04-12' }, { id: 'C-006', short: 'Brady v. Maryland', cite: '373 U.S. 83 (1963)', motionIds: ['M-9041','M-9036'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 4, firmUsage: 82, lastVerified: '2026-04-12' }, { id: 'C-007', short: 'Giglio v. United States', cite: '405 U.S. 150 (1972)', motionIds: ['M-9041'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 3, firmUsage: 42, lastVerified: '2026-04-10' }, { id: 'C-008', short: 'Daubert v. Merrell Dow', cite: '509 U.S. 579 (1993)', motionIds: ['M-9035','M-9021'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 8, firmUsage: 64, lastVerified: '2026-04-08' }, { id: 'C-009', short: 'Kumho Tire v. Carmichael', cite: '526 U.S. 137 (1999)', motionIds: ['M-9035','M-9021'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 5, firmUsage: 38, lastVerified: '2026-04-08' }, { id: 'C-010', short: 'Heckler v. Chaney', cite: '470 U.S. 821 (1985)', motionIds: ['M-9040'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 3, firmUsage: 12, lastVerified: '2026-02-12' }, { id: 'C-011', short: 'Franks v. Delaware', cite: '438 U.S. 154 (1978)', motionIds: ['M-9039'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 9, firmUsage: 28, lastVerified: '2026-04-05' }, { id: 'C-012', short: 'Comcast Corp. v. Behrend', cite: '569 U.S. 27 (2013)', motionIds: ['M-9033','M-9023'], treatment: 'caution', usesInMotion: 6, firmUsage: 24, lastVerified: '2026-04-02' }, { id: 'C-013', short: 'Wal-Mart v. Dukes', cite: '564 U.S. 338 (2011)', motionIds: ['M-9033','M-9023'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 5, firmUsage: 26, lastVerified: '2026-04-02' }, { id: 'C-014', short: 'Amex (Ohio v. American Express)', cite: '138 S.Ct. 2274 (2018)', motionIds: ['M-9033','M-9023','M-9024'],treatment: 'caution', usesInMotion: 4, firmUsage: 18, lastVerified: '2026-04-19' }, { id: 'C-015', short: 'Tellabs v. Makor', cite: '551 U.S. 308 (2007)', motionIds: [], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 0, firmUsage: 22, lastVerified: '2026-03-20' }, { id: 'C-016', short: 'Twombly v. Bell Atlantic', cite: '550 U.S. 544 (2007)', motionIds: ['M-9040','M-9024'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 4, firmUsage: 96, lastVerified: '2026-04-14' }, { id: 'C-017', short: 'Iqbal', cite: '556 U.S. 662 (2009)', motionIds: ['M-9040','M-9024'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 3, firmUsage: 104, lastVerified: '2026-04-14' }, { id: 'C-018', short: 'Williamson v. Citrix', cite: '792 F.3d 1339 (Fed. Cir. 2015)', motionIds: ['M-9022'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 7, firmUsage: 24, lastVerified: '2026-04-14' }, { id: 'C-019', short: 'Wearry v. Cain', cite: '577 U.S. 385 (2016)', motionIds: ['M-9036'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 4, firmUsage: 14, lastVerified: '2026-03-30' }, { id: 'C-020', short: 'Napue v. Illinois', cite: '360 U.S. 264 (1959)', motionIds: ['M-9036'], treatment: 'positive', usesInMotion: 2, firmUsage: 18, lastVerified: '2026-03-28' }, ], // ── CALENDAR (motion-specific deadlines) ── calendar: [ { date: '2026-04-22', motionId: 'M-9035', caption: 'Okonkwo Daubert — hearing', matter: 'US v. Okonkwo', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-04-22', motionId: 'M-9034', caption: 'Okonkwo 404(b) MIL — hearing', matter: 'US v. Okonkwo', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-04-28', motionId: 'M-9041', caption: 'Harrell Compel Brady — argument', matter: 'US v. Harrell', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-04-28', motionId: 'M-9040', caption: 'Venkat MTD + MIL — argument', matter: 'US v. Venkataraman', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-04-28', motionId: 'M-9027', caption: 'Chen D.C. Cir. detention appeal', matter: 'US v. Chen', type: 'Oral Arg', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-04-28', motionId: 'M-9036', caption: 'Barnwell Rule 33 — argument', matter: 'US v. Barnwell', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-04-28', motionId: 'M-9026', caption: 'Redstone Compel Board Minutes', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-04-30', motionId: 'M-9038', caption: 'Miller Suppress — argument', matter: 'US v. Miller', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-05-01', motionId: 'M-9019', caption: 'Sterling Protective Order — argument', matter: 'Sterling FCPA', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-05-05', motionId: 'M-9025', caption: 'Redstone Sanctions (37(e)) — argument', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-05-08', motionId: 'M-9039', caption: 'Miller Franks evidentiary hearing', matter: 'US v. Miller', type: 'Evidentiary', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-05-14', motionId: 'M-9021', caption: 'Redstone Daubert (Harlan) — due', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', type: 'Filing', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-05-22', motionId: 'M-9024', caption: 'Pacific Shipping MTD — filing due', matter: 'Pacific Shipping', type: 'Filing', urgency: 'medium' }, { date: '2026-05-22', motionId: 'M-9031', caption: 'Whitman Sentencing — hearing', matter: 'US v. Whitman', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-05-28', motionId: 'M-9042', caption: 'Redstone MSJ Opposition — argument', matter: 'Redstone v. Meridian', type: 'Argument', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-06-02', motionId: 'M-9023', caption: 'Pacific Shipping Class Cert Reply', matter: 'Pacific Shipping', type: 'Filing', urgency: 'medium' }, { date: '2026-06-03', motionId: 'M-9022', caption: 'Blackwell Markman hearing', matter: 'Blackwell IP', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'high' }, { date: '2026-06-04', motionId: 'M-9030', caption: 'Barnwell Sentencing — hearing', matter: 'US v. Barnwell', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'critical' }, { date: '2026-06-12', motionId: 'M-9033', caption: 'Greenfield Class Cert — hearing', matter: 'Greenfield Env.', type: 'Hearing', urgency: 'high' }, ], // ── JUDGES — tendency database ── judges: [ { id: 'JDG-001', name: 'V.C. J. Travis Laster', court: 'Del. Ch.', tenure: 14, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_842, grantRate: 46.2, msjGrantRate: 38.4, daubertGrantRate: 52.1, discoveryMotionGrant: 62.4, avgDaysToRuling: 42, tendency: 'balanced', notableNotes: 'Rewards well-documented record; skeptical of novel theories; favors oral argument.', firmWinRate: 71 }, { id: 'JDG-002', name: 'Alvin K. Hellerstein', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', tenure: 28, opinionsAnalyzed: 3_420, grantRate: 52.4, msjGrantRate: 46.2, daubertGrantRate: 48.6, discoveryMotionGrant: 68.2, avgDaysToRuling: 38, tendency: 'pro-movant', notableNotes: 'Pragmatic; values brevity (<25 pages); high grant rate on Rule 12.', firmWinRate: 64 }, { id: 'JDG-003', name: 'Gerald Austin McHugh Jr.', court: 'E.D. Pa.', tenure: 12, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_284, grantRate: 44.8, msjGrantRate: 34.2, daubertGrantRate: 58.4, discoveryMotionGrant: 56.2, avgDaysToRuling: 51, tendency: 'balanced', notableNotes: 'Thorough opinion writer; 8-10 week average to ruling.', firmWinRate: 58 }, { id: 'JDG-004', name: 'John Dennis Bates', court: 'D.D.C.', tenure: 18, opinionsAnalyzed: 2_180, grantRate: 48.6, msjGrantRate: 42.4, daubertGrantRate: 46.8, discoveryMotionGrant: 58.4, avgDaysToRuling: 45, tendency: 'balanced', notableNotes: 'Detention grants heavily; reversal rate on appeal 6%.', firmWinRate: 52 }, { id: 'JDG-005', name: 'Kiyo A. Matsumoto', court: 'E.D.N.Y.', tenure: 17, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_820, grantRate: 41.2, msjGrantRate: 32.4, daubertGrantRate: 44.6, discoveryMotionGrant: 64.8, avgDaysToRuling: 62, tendency: 'pro-defendant', notableNotes: 'Grants Franks hearings above avg; scrutinizes CI reliability.', firmWinRate: 82 }, { id: 'JDG-006', name: 'Valerie Caproni', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', tenure: 12, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_640, grantRate: 49.2, msjGrantRate: 44.6, daubertGrantRate: 56.2, discoveryMotionGrant: 60.4, avgDaysToRuling: 36, tendency: 'balanced', notableNotes: 'Rigorous on Daubert; granular rulings on 404(b).', firmWinRate: 74 }, { id: 'JDG-007', name: 'Paul A. Engelmayer', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', tenure: 14, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_920, grantRate: 55.4, msjGrantRate: 52.8, daubertGrantRate: 51.4, discoveryMotionGrant: 62.2, avgDaysToRuling: 32, tendency: 'pro-movant', notableNotes: 'Grants well-supported § 3553(a) variances 18% avg.', firmWinRate: 68 }, { id: 'JDG-008', name: 'Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers', court: 'N.D. Cal.', tenure: 13, opinionsAnalyzed: 1_480, grantRate: 42.8, msjGrantRate: 36.2, daubertGrantRate: 52.4, discoveryMotionGrant: 58.6, avgDaysToRuling: 48, tendency: 'pro-defendant', notableNotes: 'Class certification rulings lean plaintiff; strict on predominance.', firmWinRate: 61 }, { id: 'JDG-009', name: 'Lewis J. Liman', court: 'S.D.N.Y.', tenure: 6, opinionsAnalyzed: 680, grantRate: 50.2, msjGrantRate: 42.4, daubertGrantRate: 48.6, discoveryMotionGrant: 58.4, avgDaysToRuling: 42, tendency: 'balanced', notableNotes: 'Background as trial lawyer; detailed bench rulings.', firmWinRate: 56 }, { id: 'JDG-010', name: 'Gregory B. Williams', court: 'D. Del.', tenure: 5, opinionsAnalyzed: 420, grantRate: 54.4, msjGrantRate: 48.2, daubertGrantRate: 56.4, discoveryMotionGrant: 58.2, avgDaysToRuling: 58, tendency: 'pro-movant', notableNotes: 'Strong Markman rulings; claim-construction orientation.', firmWinRate: 72 }, ], // ── OPPOSING COUNSEL ── opposingCounsel: [ { id: 'OC-001', firm: 'Harrison Defense Group', practice: 'Commercial Litigation', typicalMotions: ['MSJ','Motion to Compel','Protective Order'], motionsFiledVsUs: 14, ourWinRate: 71, theirWinRate: 29, avgRespTime: 28, notable: 'Strong on privilege; weak on discovery disputes.' }, { id: 'OC-002', firm: 'Cravath Antitrust Team', practice: 'Antitrust', typicalMotions: ['MTD','Class Cert Opposition'], motionsFiledVsUs: 8, ourWinRate: 63, theirWinRate: 37, avgRespTime: 34, notable: 'Aggressive briefing; strong economic-expert relationships.' }, { id: 'OC-003', firm: 'AUSA Southern District of N.Y.',practice: 'Federal Criminal', typicalMotions: ['Opposition','Detention'], motionsFiledVsUs: 22, ourWinRate: 48, theirWinRate: 52, avgRespTime: 14, notable: 'Brady-compliance disputes common; receptive to scope negotiation.' }, { id: 'OC-004', firm: 'AUSA Eastern District of Pa.', practice: 'Federal Criminal', typicalMotions: ['Opposition','MIL'], motionsFiledVsUs: 6, ourWinRate: 58, theirWinRate: 42, avgRespTime: 21, notable: 'Novel theories engaged in good faith; slow production.' }, { id: 'OC-005', firm: 'AUSA District of Columbia', practice: 'FCPA / White Collar', typicalMotions: ['Opposition','Protective Order'], motionsFiledVsUs: 12, ourWinRate: 54, theirWinRate: 46, avgRespTime: 18, notable: 'FCPA Unit highly specialized; extensive use of in-camera reviews.' }, { id: 'OC-006', firm: 'DOJ Appellate Section', practice: 'Federal Appellate', typicalMotions: ['Appellate Brief','Opposition'], motionsFiledVsUs: 4, ourWinRate: 42, theirWinRate: 58, avgRespTime: 45, notable: 'Strategic ceding of weak points; high-quality briefs.' }, { id: 'OC-007', firm: 'Verge IP Counsel (Fish)', practice: 'Patent Litigation', typicalMotions: ['Markman Opposition','MTD'], motionsFiledVsUs: 6, ourWinRate: 68, theirWinRate: 32, avgRespTime: 32, notable: 'Aggressive on § 101 eligibility; claim-construction conservative.' }, { id: 'OC-008', firm: 'Greenfield Legal (Latham)', practice: 'Environmental / Class', typicalMotions: ['Opposition','MTD'], motionsFiledVsUs: 5, ourWinRate: 62, theirWinRate: 38, avgRespTime: 28, notable: 'Strong expert-witness preparation; weak on standing.' }, { id: 'OC-009', firm: 'Defense Consortium (MDL)', practice: 'Antitrust / MDL', typicalMotions: ['MTD','Opposition','MIL'], motionsFiledVsUs: 10, ourWinRate: 56, theirWinRate: 44, avgRespTime: 42, notable: 'Coordinated filings; varying quality across firms.' }, { id: 'OC-010', firm: 'SEC Enforcement', practice: 'Securities', typicalMotions: ['CID Response','Settlement Negotiation'], motionsFiledVsUs: 3, ourWinRate: 48, theirWinRate: 52, avgRespTime: 60, notable: 'Data-driven approach; willingness to narrow scope.' }, ], // ── ORAL ARGUMENT PREPS ── oralArgs: [ { id: 'OA-001', motionId: 'M-9027', caption: 'Chen D.C. Cir. Detention Appeal', date: '2026-04-28', argueBy: 'M. Kirkland', mootsScheduled: 2, mootsCompleted: 1, notesCount: 18, witnessesConfirmed: 0, preparationPct: 78, readiness: 'on-track' }, { id: 'OA-002', motionId: 'M-9042', caption: 'Redstone MSJ Opposition', date: '2026-05-28', argueBy: 'M. Kirkland', mootsScheduled: 3, mootsCompleted: 1, notesCount: 34, witnessesConfirmed: 0, preparationPct: 52, readiness: 'on-track' }, { id: 'OA-003', motionId: 'M-9040', caption: 'Venkat MTD Hearing', date: '2026-04-28', argueBy: 'L. Torres', mootsScheduled: 2, mootsCompleted: 2, notesCount: 28, witnessesConfirmed: 0, preparationPct: 88, readiness: 'ready' }, { id: 'OA-004', motionId: 'M-9038', caption: 'Miller Suppression Hearing', date: '2026-04-30', argueBy: 'J. Park', mootsScheduled: 1, mootsCompleted: 1, notesCount: 22, witnessesConfirmed: 3, preparationPct: 84, readiness: 'ready' }, { id: 'OA-005', motionId: 'M-9039', caption: 'Miller Franks Evidentiary Hearing', date: '2026-05-08', argueBy: 'J. Park', mootsScheduled: 2, mootsCompleted: 1, notesCount: 32, witnessesConfirmed: 4, preparationPct: 68, readiness: 'on-track' }, { id: 'OA-006', motionId: 'M-9041', caption: 'Harrell Compel Brady', date: '2026-04-28', argueBy: 'L. Torres', mootsScheduled: 1, mootsCompleted: 0, notesCount: 14, witnessesConfirmed: 0, preparationPct: 58, readiness: 'on-track' }, { id: 'OA-007', motionId: 'M-9035', caption: 'Okonkwo Daubert', date: '2026-04-22', argueBy: 'M. Kirkland', mootsScheduled: 1, mootsCompleted: 1, notesCount: 18, witnessesConfirmed: 1, preparationPct: 92, readiness: 'ready' }, ], // ── ANALYTICS ── (win rates, trends) analytics: { winRateByType: [ { type: 'MSJ Opposition', filed: 18, granted: 12, partial: 4, denied: 2, winRate: 77.8 }, { type: 'MTD', filed: 14, granted: 8, partial: 2, denied: 4, winRate: 64.3 }, { type: 'Motion to Compel', filed: 28, granted: 18, partial: 6, denied: 4, winRate: 75.0 }, { type: 'Daubert', filed: 11, granted: 7, partial: 3, denied: 1, winRate: 77.3 }, { type: 'MIL', filed: 22, granted: 14, partial: 6, denied: 2, winRate: 77.3 }, { type: 'Franks Hearing', filed: 4, granted: 3, partial: 0, denied: 1, winRate: 75.0 }, { type: 'Class Cert', filed: 6, granted: 4, partial: 1, denied: 1, winRate: 75.0 }, { type: 'Sanctions (Rule 37)', filed: 8, granted: 4, partial: 2, denied: 2, winRate: 62.5 }, { type: 'Bail Review', filed: 5, granted: 2, partial: 0, denied: 3, winRate: 40.0 }, { type: 'Markman', filed: 7, granted: 5, partial: 1, denied: 1, winRate: 78.6 }, ], winRateByAttorney: [ { attorney: 'M. Kirkland', motions: 42, granted: 28, partial: 8, denied: 6, winRate: 76.2 }, { attorney: 'L. Torres', motions: 38, granted: 24, partial: 10, denied: 4, winRate: 76.3 }, { attorney: 'J. Park', motions: 18, granted: 11, partial: 5, denied: 2, winRate: 75.0 }, { attorney: 'S. Chen', motions: 22, granted: 14, partial: 4, denied: 4, winRate: 72.7 }, { attorney: 'A. Petrov', motions: 12, granted: 8, partial: 2, denied: 2, winRate: 75.0 }, { attorney: 'R. Vasquez', motions: 14, granted: 8, partial: 3, denied: 3, winRate: 67.9 }, ], monthlyTrend: [ { m: 'May 25', filed: 18, granted: 12 }, { m: 'Jun 25', filed: 22, granted: 14 }, { m: 'Jul 25', filed: 20, granted: 14 }, { m: 'Aug 25', filed: 19, granted: 13 }, { m: 'Sep 25', filed: 24, granted: 16 }, { m: 'Oct 25', filed: 26, granted: 19 }, { m: 'Nov 25', filed: 22, granted: 16 }, { m: 'Dec 25', filed: 16, granted: 11 }, { m: 'Jan 26', filed: 24, granted: 18 }, { m: 'Feb 26', filed: 28, granted: 22 }, { m: 'Mar 26', filed: 32, granted: 24 }, { m: 'Apr 26', filed: 22, granted: 16 }, ], }, // ── RULINGS (recent court orders received) ── rulings: [ { id: 'R-101', motionId: 'M-9039', caption: 'Miller — Franks Hearing', outcome: 'Granted', rulingDate: '2026-04-18', daysToRuling: 57, judge: 'Matsumoto', oneLineSummary: 'Evidentiary hearing granted on 3 affidavit misstatements re CI-2.' }, { id: 'R-100', motionId: 'M-9029', caption: 'Harrell — Sever Count 4', outcome: 'Denied', rulingDate: '2026-04-14', daysToRuling: 31, judge: 'Hellerstein', oneLineSummary: 'Rule 14 joinder balance does not preclude trial of § 1028A with Counts 1-3.' }, { id: 'R-099', motionId: 'M-9035', caption: 'Okonkwo — Daubert', outcome: 'Granted in Part', rulingDate: '2026-04-12', daysToRuling: 25, judge: 'Caproni', oneLineSummary: 'Gov\'t expert permitted on methodology; excluded on ultimate issue.' }, { id: 'R-098', motionId: 'M-9034', caption: 'Okonkwo — 404(b)', outcome: 'Granted in Part', rulingDate: '2026-04-12', daysToRuling: 23, judge: 'Caproni', oneLineSummary: 'Prior 2018 investigation excluded as propensity; admissible for intent if opened.' }, { id: 'R-097', motionId: 'M-9032', caption: 'Ó Briain — Quash Subpoena', outcome: 'Denied', rulingDate: '2026-03-25', daysToRuling: 15, judge: 'Liman', oneLineSummary: 'No privilege attached to pre-engagement consulting advice.' }, { id: 'R-096', motionId: 'M-9028', caption: 'Chen — Bail Review', outcome: 'Denied', rulingDate: '2026-03-18', daysToRuling: 14, judge: 'Bates', oneLineSummary: 'Flight risk finding confirmed; detention appropriate.' }, { id: 'R-095', motionId: null, caption: 'Greenfield — MTD (2025)', outcome: 'Denied', rulingDate: '2026-01-28', daysToRuling: 42, judge: 'Gonzalez Rogers', oneLineSummary: 'Class allegations plausibly pled under Twombly/Iqbal framework.' }, { id: 'R-094', motionId: null, caption: 'Thornton — MIL', outcome: 'Granted', rulingDate: '2026-01-18', daysToRuling: 28, judge: 'Reynolds', oneLineSummary: 'Attorney-drafted will narrative excluded; limited to contemporaneous records.' }, { id: 'R-093', motionId: null, caption: 'Sterling — Protective', outcome: 'Granted', rulingDate: '2026-01-10', daysToRuling: 19, judge: 'Bates', oneLineSummary: 'Confidential investigative materials may be sealed for in-camera review.' }, { id: 'R-092', motionId: null, caption: 'Blackwell — MSJ Invalidity', outcome: 'Denied', rulingDate: '2025-12-20', daysToRuling: 52, judge: 'Williams', oneLineSummary: 'Material disputes on prior art preclude summary judgment.' }, ], // ── TEMPLATES ── templates: [ { id: 'T-001', name: 'MSJ Opposition — Commercial Litigation', category: 'Motion', words: 12000, sections: 6, coreCites: ['MFW','Aronson','Celotex','Anderson'], usedBy: 18, updated: '2026-04-10', author: 'M. Kirkland', description: 'MSJ opposition in commercial fraud / fiduciary duty context. Pre-built sections for BJR, MFW, entire-fairness.' }, { id: 'T-002', name: 'Motion to Dismiss — Rule 12(b)(6)', category: 'Motion', words: 8000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Twombly','Iqbal'], usedBy: 34, updated: '2026-03-14', author: 'Litigation', description: 'Standard 12(b)(6) template with plausibility framework and common defenses.' }, { id: 'T-003', name: 'Daubert Motion to Exclude Expert', category: 'Motion', words: 5000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Daubert','Kumho Tire','Rule 702'], usedBy: 22, updated: '2026-04-02', author: 'Litigation', description: 'Motion to exclude expert under Rule 702 / Daubert. Includes 2023 Rule 702 amendment arguments.' }, { id: 'T-004', name: 'Motion to Compel — Brady (Criminal)', category: 'Motion', words: 5000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Brady','Kyles','Giglio','Bagley'], usedBy: 14, updated: '2026-02-24', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Brady compel motion with Kyles materiality framework.' }, { id: 'T-005', name: 'Motion in Limine — Rule 403 Prejudice', category: 'Motion', words: 4000, sections: 4, coreCites: ['FRE 403','Old Chief'], usedBy: 26, updated: '2026-03-28', author: 'Litigation', description: 'MIL template for FRE 403 prejudice exclusions.' }, { id: 'T-006', name: 'Class Certification Reply — Antitrust', category: 'Brief', words: 10000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Comcast','Wal-Mart','Amex','Tyson Foods'], usedBy: 8, updated: '2026-04-02', author: 'Antitrust Group', description: 'Reply template for class cert — predominance, typicality, damages.' }, { id: 'T-007', name: 'Motion to Suppress — 4th Amendment', category: 'Motion', words: 7000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Katz','Schneckloth','Franks','Gates'], usedBy: 12, updated: '2026-02-20', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Suppression motion with backup consent-coercion theory.' }, { id: 'T-008', name: 'Franks Hearing Motion', category: 'Motion', words: 6000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Franks','Aguilar','Gates'], usedBy: 6, updated: '2026-02-20', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Franks motion challenging officer affiant misstatements.' }, { id: 'T-009', name: 'Sentencing Memo — § 3553(a) Variance', category: 'Memo', words: 8000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Rita','Gall','Kimbrough','Booker'], usedBy: 28, updated: '2026-04-15', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: '§ 3553(a) variance template. Includes age, charitable works, collateral consequences.' }, { id: 'T-010', name: 'Motion for Bail Review — § 3145(b)', category: 'Motion', words: 6000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['§ 3142','Salerno','Stack v. Boyle'], usedBy: 8, updated: '2026-03-04', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Bail review template. Includes individualized-consideration framework.' }, { id: 'T-011', name: 'Markman Claim Construction Brief', category: 'Brief', words: 12000, sections: 7, coreCites: ['Williamson','Phillips','Nautilus','O2 Micro'], usedBy: 11, updated: '2026-03-22', author: 'IP Practice', description: 'Claim construction brief with sections per claim term, § 112(f) analysis.' }, { id: 'T-012', name: 'Motion for Sanctions — Rule 37(e)', category: 'Motion', words: 8000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Rule 37(e)','Zubulake','Pension Committee'], usedBy: 9, updated: '2026-02-14', author: 'Litigation', description: 'Rule 37(e) adverse-inference sanctions for ESI spoliation.' }, { id: 'T-013', name: 'Motion for Summary Judgment — Defense', category: 'Motion', words: 14000, sections: 6, coreCites: ['Celotex','Anderson','Matsushita'], usedBy: 16, updated: '2026-03-10', author: 'Litigation', description: 'Defense MSJ template with no-issue-of-fact framework.' }, { id: 'T-014', name: 'Protective Order Motion', category: 'Motion', words: 4000, sections: 4, coreCites: ['Rule 26(c)','Seattle Times'], usedBy: 14, updated: '2026-04-14', author: 'Litigation', description: 'Protective order for sealing or restricting access.' }, { id: 'T-015', name: 'Motion for New Trial — Rule 33', category: 'Motion', words: 6000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Rule 33','Berry','Wearry'], usedBy: 4, updated: '2026-03-30', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Post-verdict new-trial motion based on Brady or newly-discovered evidence.' }, { id: 'T-016', name: 'Appellate Brief — Federal Criminal', category: 'Appellate', words: 14000, sections: 5, coreCites: ['Anders','Kastigar'], usedBy: 9, updated: '2026-04-04', author: 'Criminal Defense', description: 'Federal criminal appellate opening brief template.' }, ], // ── ACTIVITY ── activity: [ { id: 'MN-A-001', time: '10:55 AM', actor: 'M. Kirkland', action: 'Filed motion', target: 'M-9019 Sterling Protective Order', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-002', time: '10:42 AM', actor: 'Court — E.D.N.Y.', action: 'Order received', target: 'R-101 Miller — Franks hearing GRANTED', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-003', time: '10:28 AM', actor: 'L. Torres', action: 'Updated cite status', target: '6 cites verified on M-9041 Harrell Brady', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-004', time: '10:14 AM', actor: 'System', action: 'Deadline alert', target: 'M-9021 Redstone Daubert — filing due in 23 days', severity: 'warn' }, { id: 'MN-A-005', time: '09:58 AM', actor: 'M. Kirkland', action: 'Moot completed', target: 'OA-001 Chen D.C. Cir. — moot #1 complete', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-006', time: '09:42 AM', actor: 'S. Chen', action: 'Added section', target: 'M-9024 Pacific Shipping MTD — § III SOL argument drafted', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-007', time: '09:20 AM', actor: 'System', action: 'Cite health report', target: '3 cites flagged for re-verification across motion queue', severity: 'warn' }, { id: 'MN-A-008', time: '09:08 AM', actor: 'J. Park', action: 'Uploaded brief bank entry', target: 'BB-006 Franks Hearing — updated with Miller victory', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-009', time: 'Yesterday', actor: 'Court — S.D.N.Y.', action: 'Order received', target: 'R-099 Okonkwo — Daubert GRANTED in PART', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-010', time: 'Yesterday', actor: 'Court — S.D.N.Y.', action: 'Order received', target: 'R-098 Okonkwo — 404(b) GRANTED in PART', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-011', time: 'Yesterday', actor: 'R. Vasquez', action: 'Filed motion', target: 'M-9031 Whitman Sentencing Memorandum', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-012', time: '2 days ago', actor: 'System', action: 'Ruling notification', target: '3 rulings expected this week (41 motions in submission)', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-013', time: '2 days ago', actor: 'L. Torres', action: 'Created draft', target: 'M-9020 Redstone MIL Harlan Scope', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-014', time: '3 days ago', actor: 'System', action: 'Win-rate update', target: 'Firm avg win rate updated: 71.4% (YTD)', severity: 'info' }, { id: 'MN-A-015', time: '3 days ago', actor: 'A. Petrov', action: 'Filed motion', target: 'M-9022 Blackwell Markman Brief', severity: 'info' }, ], }; window.MOTIONS_DATA = MOTIONS_DATA;